I’m not sure why someone thought that I would be a good
person to cover this topic. I don’t know why I want to write it either, but I
do. So before I go any further, allow me to issue this disclaimer:
Understand that the following represents ONLY the opinion of
the owner of this blog. It does not in any way reflect the blogosphere as a
whole, or what the owner of this blog thinks of the blogosphere as a whole, or
anything to do with anyone, anywhere, that has ever written a blog, commented
on a blog, or considered blogs at all, or even those people that are all like,
“What the fuck is a blog?” Most of what is written below is purely the owner of
this blog talking out of her ass.
Ok. Moving on. Please feel free to add your own opinions in
the comments and to tell me when I’m wrong as well. I will respond to comments
today in the comment section (instead of just emailing you all back) so we can
have a running dialog.
Here, here and here is what some other people have written
on this subject. Go read those first. I’ll wait.
Now, my take.
1. THINK about who is reading your blog.
IF you are part of a community and you want to STAY in it.
The Infertility Blogosphere IS a community, and even though I have lots of
readers these days that are not infertile, I am still a part of that community.
Obviously, I can say whatever I want—it is my blog, after all—but I don’t have
to be an asshole.
I have been burned for this one. Back when I was pregnant
(ah, the good ol’ days) I lamented the fact that I was having twin boys and
would never get to have the little girl I’d always dreamed of. There were lots
of people who understood how I felt, but because this is an infertility blog,
there were a couple of folks having really bad days (like my Black Day
yesterday) that were deeply hurt. While I was telling my own truth, I could
have framed it in a way that might have hurt others less. I’ve also made a
couple of stupid plunders—like the day I named specific names of other bloggers
who’d been through similar situations to my pregnancy but ended up with
children (and lamenting the fact that they got off “easier” than I did—nice,
huh?). Not a good idea; I ended up losing a friend and mentor.
So while I do believe it’s important to be honest—and I am,
usually, deeply honest here—it’s also important to not be an asshat. It’s kind
of like when you broke up with the guy with the small penis and told him it was
really about you not being ready to be in a relationship. He didn’t have to
know that you meant you weren’t ready to be in a relationship with his tiny
penis. You know?
2. Do NOT think about people reading your blog.
Ha! I’m confusing you, aren’t I? Don’t think about the fact
that people who are reading you may not agree with you. Don’t try to mold your
opinions to please everyone. It’s not possible. Again, you can sensitive, but
you should be truthful.
3. Links
Now, I’ve never asked anyone if I can link to their blog but
according to a couple of those other write ups, I should, especially if it’s a
small blog. My feelings are that if you link to your blog in my comment section
I can link to your blog in the text body. Otherwise, I think linking is pretty
fair game.
Where I get confused is on the difference between trackbacks
and links. I like when people do trackbacks, because then I’m notified that
you’ve linked to me, yet I have never done one (because I haven’t, um, figured
out how…).
I do know that you should NEVER import images from another
site into your blog, but you can link to those images at will. A subtle but
important difference.
Linking to news articles, etc, is never an issue. I’m sure
they are happy for the traffic.
4. Comments
Ah, commenting. Is there any area in Blogland that is more
fraught with etiquette issues?
I don’t think so. Again, this is just MY opinion.
Since I have a public blog, and I accept comments, I feel it
is absolutely imperative that I accept a few basic truths:
-People will disagree with me. Vehemently.
-People can be assholes and will randomly post comments like
“you are a stupid fat bitch and I canT believe anyoneever reads you blogg”
-People will read this blog and never, ever post a comment.
I rarely edit or delete comments. I do edit out my city’s
name if someone posts it, because I like to pretend that I have a teeny shred
of anonymity and you all don’t know exactly where I live. I also delete the
“fat pig” comments that are random and have nothing to do with anything. And
one time I deleted comments from another blogger because she was responding to
something I’d since edited out of an entry and I wanted to prevent a full-out
war.
But I’ve left all of the comments my trolls have posted. I
might block them from posting, but I’ve left the original comments up. Mostly
because the truly awful ones have been related to issues surrounding abortion
and choice and I think it’s critical that we have a glimpse into the brains of
a militantly anti-choice person—even if that person is calling me a murderer
and telling me my sons died for no reason and could have survived if I’d delivered
them.
But people that post thoughtful responses disagreeing with
me are deeply, deeply valuable to me. I can’t believe the number of
friendships that have developed between me and people I vehemently disagree
with because we just took a moment to LISTEN to each other. Discussion is
always useful.
What isn’t useful is people leaping to my defense against
those that disagree with me and make it personal. Reputing what they say is
fine, but calling them ‘stupid’ or ‘bitch’ isn’t really helpful. I prefer we
play nice.
Leaping to my defense against the truly evil trolls is
appreciated, however.
As far as reading and not commenting goes; that’s an
interesting question. Someone (I can’t remember who said this and I’m sorry for
not linking to you) recently said that reading a blog and not commenting is
like going to someone’s house for dinner and eating the meal but refusing
conversation. While I love getting comments, I don’t feel that strongly about
it; I do believe it’s ok if you would prefer to just read, but I wonder who you
are. I’m thrilled at every “de-lurker.”
I think a lot of people view reading blogs like they do
reading magazines; it’s not a conversation, it’s entertainment or information.
I understand. I know that I’ve recently made a concerted effort to get back in
the habit of commenting on the blogs I read (I got out of the habit because of
Bloglines). I won’t comment on every entry—often there are already lots of
folks who’ve said what I was going to say—but I do try to comment once in a while.
Lastly, some people may not like them, but I love comments
that simply say, “I’m thinking of you!” or “I agree!” Really. I absolutely
LOVED how many people came out and admitted to liking Ayn Rand’s work; I really
thought I was alone on that one. All slaps on the back are appreciated, hell, craved.
5. More About Comments
I like to privately email responses to my commenters. I know
not everyone does it, and I don’t expect them to (although I’m secretly
thrilled when someone like Grrl or Julie emails me back). Other people prefer
to respond right in the comment section, which I almost never do (unless I’m
trying to clarify something or asking people to play nice).
Which do you prefer? I know that when I see a blogger
responding in her comment section I feel better knowing that she’s reading all
the comments (anyone who says they don’t read all their comments is so totally
lying—we are absolute gluttons for attention, us bloggers), but if she doesn’t
respond to MY comment, I feel oddly neglected (yeah, I’m crazy like that).
Hence my choice to email everyone back so that you KNOW I read what you wrote.
Interested to hear what you all think.
6. Blogrolling
Honestly, I am CLUELESS on this subject. I don’t have every
blog I read regularly blogrolled, and I know my blogroll is out of date. I
linked to Julie’s blog to cover all the infertiles, but there are lots of
others that I read.
I don’t really pay attention to who links to me, although I
enjoy it when I see a referral from a blogger I’ve never heard of before.
So tell me what you all think about this one, cause I suck
at the whole blogroll thing.
7. Open Mind, Open Heart
I think the thing I’ve learned the most is to just keep my
heart and mind open to new ideas. Just the other day I was emailing back and
forth with a commenter who calls herself a fundamentalist Christian about
Madeline L’Engels books; I assumed, incorrectly, that Ms. L’Engles open
acceptance of evolution would make that book off limits. Not only was I wrong
about that, she’s a Harry Potter fan too. So not ALL people who call themselves
“fundamentalist Christians” are whack jobs! Who knew?
Once again, a commenter forces me to look at my strongly
held opinions and re-evaluate them. I absolutely LOVE this.
I think that’s about all I have to say on the subject; I
imagine you will have loads more to add and I’m counting on you all to cover
all the stuff I missed.
I’ll leave you with this very funny link about “Blog
Depression” (via Dawn).