Uniting Against Breastfeeding
I'm sure by now you've already heard about Judith Warner's latest blog post at the New York Times talking about banning the breast pump. It is, of course, in response to Hanna Rosin's Atlantic article about the case against breast feeding.
I don't need to respond, because other mothers have already done it so well. Read Anne's great point by point response here (her politics may differ from yours, but that doesn't mean her response isn't perfect). But of course I'm going to. Heh.
I'm trying to go beyond my initial reaction, which is that these women are idiots, and if they have husbands who find them unattractive because of using a breast pump, well, they are then also married to idiots. But that argument holds no merit, and I know that.
So I'm also trying to step away from my own core beliefs: that breast feeding IS, indeed, best, otherwise why on earth would we be designed this way? While this might be my belief, I do understand that breastfeeding isn't actually for everyone, and it's also not possible for lots of women, so I've worked hard on not being judgmental about it. I'm presented with lots of opportunities to not judge here in Philadelphia: we have one of the lowest rates of breastfed babies in the United States, and the vast majority of other mothers I meet have never breast fed their children (there is little support even at our local hospitals; Tori was fed formula before I ever got to see her, and this is a common experience for moms in our area).
But even if I put aside both the idiot and the judgmental arguments, I'm still left with a pretty strong feeling of disgust at both of these articles.
First of all, these article REEK of privilege. The fact is, while there may be a certain amount of pressure to breast feed in rich, well educated mom circles, according to the CDC only 65% of babies are nursed in the hospital, only 27% are still nursed at six months, and 12% are still nursing at a year (full disclosure: I nursed Tori -- after a very rocky start -- until she was 21 months old and self-weaned). So this idea that these women are 'rebelling' against the 'militant' pro breastfeeding mafia is a bunch of fucking bullshit. These women that didn't like nursing their children (and using a breast pump) are in fact in the majority, and by a wide fucking mile.
Secondly, the anti-pump manifesto there is simply incomprehensible to me, much the same way everything Rush Limbaugh says in incomprehensible. Why on earth, after all the work women have done to gain even a hint of equity in the work place, would some women want to take away a tool (a "grotesque ritual" according to Judith Warner) like the breast pump away from working women? It seems to me that these women must not have actually NEEDED to pump much because I cannot use any other rational that would make the objections make sense.
But the overarching issue here is a familiar one. Why, oh why, are mothers so damned judgmental about mothering? And I say this recognizing the irony that here I am, a mother, struggling to understand without judgment (and failing) these mothers that wrote these two anti-breastfeeding articles. But my point is this; it's completely FINE for these women to feel this way. Whatever. Don't nurse your children or use a breastpump; I truly don't give a fuck.
But don't pontificate and act as if your ideas are a) brilliant and b) revolutionary. Because then we reserve the right to holler "bullshit" and point out the fallacies in your arguments.
So, basically, I call bullshit about these two articles. What do you think?





